Nice Guy or Bad Boy?

Thursday, November 19, 2009
By Meg

James Dean by Stern Phil

“Nice guys finish last” seems to be the mantra when it comes to nice-guy-love-stories.  Such tales are usually riddled with unappreciated, broken-hearted blokes who wear their hearts on their sleeves, giving it their all in every relationship, but being rejected or dumped time and time again for the simple reason that they are “too nice” or rather “too easy”.

“George” is one of these nice guys.  I’ve known George almost all my life. He is a consummate gentleman – chivalrous, honest, reliable, trustworthy, loyal, generous, considerate, kind – and possesses a profound respect for women.  A woman never needs to fear that he won’t call or follow through on a plan. And he won’t disappear after a few dates, or worst of all, feign romantic interest if there is none.  When George is in love, he makes it known, regaling the girl with self-composed piano tunes inspired by his love or beautifully arranged mini-herb gardens used later to cook the most delicious meals or romantic late night outings under the stars.

Women love George for all his sweetness, humor and fun, but that love is usually of the platonic sort or eventually ends up as such. They look for George when their ego is in need of mending, especially after a heart break, as he is an ideal rebound lover. George has an ability to build women back up when they are at their lowest, making them feel whole, special and confident again, and unknowingly, readying them for the next brute that comes along.  When the girl is ready to move on, George graciously suffers through all the cliché excuses and reasons like “I’m not ready to get serious,” “I’m too busy for a relationship right now,” “You deserve more”, etc. with the understanding of a saint. And just weeks or months later, he would discover that these women are already hitched to the next less congenial and not-so-nice guy, where those excuses and reasons given to George no longer apply, at least not for his successors.

As I reflect on George’s love life, contrasting it against the love lives of my female friends, I can’t help but wonder why women would forego nice guys like George, preferring the not-so-nice guys.  On paper, George is the guy most women want, though in reality, we find ourselves chasing after the bad boys who inevitably disappoint by forgetting to call, disappearing for weeks on end or flaking on agreed-upon plans, leaving us in a perpetual state of confusion. So I must ask all of us bad-boy chasing women: Is the challenge and thrill of chasing such a man worth the frustration and disappointment?

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

Subscribe to Blog
Love in the 21st Century on Facebook

Tags: , , , , , , ,

4 Responses to “Nice Guy or Bad Boy?”

  1. Yasin GUNES

    Ladies,
    We also have similar dilemmas, choosing good loosing fun or chosing bad and having smth. else…

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    #370
  2. Laetitia

    Bad boys are a pain and thriller while Nice guys are comforting and boring.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    #353
  3. karishma

    its not worth chasing a man who won’t appreciate you for who you are, its kinda tiring actually. i agree with u meg, there aren’t enough Georges’ out there. this is going to sound strange but its like in the animal world (yes i love animal planet) you chase your mate, fight for them, if you don’t you are left alone. guys and girls act on their ‘animal’ instinct. the brute gets the girl and the nice guy gets a friend. however what people forget is that we have been gifted with intelligence.. and humor of a level that separates us from animal behavior. not enough people recognize that when choosing their mates. i like goofballs, cheesy jokes and someone who is easy on my eyes, i don’t know many brutes like that, do you? :-) welcome back!

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

    #118
  4. Meg

    Hello All,

    It’s been a while but I’m back. Been traveling across the Atlantic, from the new world to old and picking up some god-forsaken Euro-flu along the way. It’s been a long road to recovery and I’m finally finding my way back.

    So here’s a piece I started a few weeks ago, in response to Robert who commented on the “21st Century Goddesses & the Men Who Don’t Deserve Them” article. Hopefully, this story will receive Robert’s approval, providing a more positive light on men. (Robert – I do think there are some wonderful men out there, just not enough of them unfortunately.)

    Anyway, I hope you all enjoy reading this and stay tuned for more.

    Meg

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

    #117

Leave a Reply

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes

Words of Wisdom

Loading Quotes...

Recent Comments

  • Will I Marry Me? (8)
    • Steve: Rather than asking ourselves if someone could marry us, shouldn’t the...
    • George Dimi: Initially, the person who shattered the trust will need to work hard to...
  • Dating Is Not for “The Frail” (10)
    • kevin: i’m in this band you speak of and just ran into this blog. it’s...
  • Nice Guy or Bad Boy? (4)
    • Yasin GUNES: Ladies, We also have similar dilemmas, choosing good loosing fun or...
    • Laetitia: Bad boys are a pain and thriller while Nice guys are comforting and boring.
  • Guys and Dolls (7)
    • Wendell Lupercio: je suis fan aussi
    • Charlotte-Louise: Hey Meg, We all miss your postings. Looking forward to reading new...
    • CoreyTess: Meg, This got me thinking.. so much so that I wrote a blog post in response...
    • Alena: I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would...
    • JM: Meg, I’m not sure what your educational or professional background is, but...

Search